We changed from Daylight Saving Time to Standard Time three weeks ago. I am still having trouble adjusting. As I sat at the computer last night, ready to research a plant for this blog, my eyes drifted over to the window. Dark, cool, rainy. It must be approaching 10pm, I reasoned. A glance at the clock said it was just a few minutes after 7pm. How is that possible? Instead of delving into horticultural mysteries, I decided to investigate the background of Daylight Saving Time (“DST”).
First, notice that it is Daylight Saving Time, not Savings. Even though Benjamin Franklin is thought to be the originating party, time changes were suggested by George Washington back in 1784 as a means of conserving candlewax. Instead, he suggested that sleeping residents could be roused by the sound of church bells or even cannon fire. This seems absurd now, but that was a different time. His suggestion went nowhere. In 1916, Germany established DST as a way to conserve fuel during World War I. The US followed for seven months before reverting to Standard Time. DST was enacted again by President Franklin Roosevelt in February 1942. This change was for all year, and it was labeled “War Time” (WWII).
In 1945, Congress decided to allow states to make their own decisions about keeping DST or reverting to Standard Time. The result was chaos. Train schedules were impossible to establish without nation-wide consistency. Interstate travel and trade were confused. Neighboring states might be the same, or might not.
Beginning in 1966, our nation’s clocks were reset on the first Sunday of April and the last Sunday of November. In 2007, the reset changed to the second Sunday in March and the first Sunday in November. This alteration was part of the Energy Policy Act of 2005, signed by then-President Bush as part of a larger plan to reduce fossil fuel usage and improve air quality.
All states now follow DST except Arizona and Hawai’i. The change pleases golfers and shop owners, allowing for more people to be out playing and shopping before the onset of darkness. Farmers, on the other hand, want to get started early and say that it confuses their animals. I’ve never seen cattle wearing watches or consulting their phones, so I assume that the displeasure is with feeding times. [If you are a farmer who is unhappy with the change, please feel free to enlighten me.] About 70 countries follow the change, while India, China, Japan, and most African countries do not.
Time changes disrupt our bodies’ natural rhythms, which can manifest itself with increased car accidents, job site injuries, short tempers, and even heart attacks. I am one of those who prefer we pick one or the other, and remain with it instead of the twice-yearly change. I don’t think I am in the minority, since 19 states have requested that DST become permanent. In response, Congress proposed the Sunshine Protection Act of 2023. It died before passage, and was not resurrected in 2024. Perhaps we will see a change in the future.
And I finally learned why the drop-an-hour/add-an-hour change happens at 2am instead of some other time. In 1966, there were no Amtrak trains leaving New York City at 2am, so this was the least disruptive choice and had the lowest impact on travelers.
